Home

 › 

Uncategorized

 › 

Energy Aspects’ Amrita Sen Says Shipping Costs Now Make Up a Big Part of What Refiners Pay for Oil

Ink illustration: a small gray oil drum beside a blank orange postage stamp several times its size, leaning against it.

Energy Aspects’ Amrita Sen Says Shipping Costs Now Make Up a Big Part of What Refiners Pay for Oil

Quick Read

  • Saudi Arabia's price cut looks like a supply story, but one analyst says the real driver is something most oil watchers aren't even tracking.
  • A single cargo of Gulf crude can now require multiple vessels and weeks of extra transit. That reality changes everything about how you read the headline price.
  • If one energy analyst is right, the oil price on your screen may be telling you almost nothing about what refiners actually pay.
  • Building a portfolio and living off one are two completely different skills, and almost nobody teaches the second. This problem is what The Definitive Guide to Retirement Income helps, and it is free today. Read more here. (Sponsor)

Where we heard itCNBC’s Squawk Box, Oct. 2, 2026. Speaker: Amrita Sen, founder and director of research at Energy Aspects.

Saudi Arabia caught the oil market off guard by cutting its November crude prices for Asian buyers. Reuters reported that Saudi Arabia unexpectedly cut November oil prices to Asia to 6-year lows. A Bloomberg headline described the main price to Asia as the lowest in six years. investingLive reported that Saudi Aramco cut the Arab Light price to Asia by $3, with investingLive calling it the widest discount since 2020.

Most investors read the move as a straightforward supply story. Amrita Sen, founder of Energy Aspects, reads it as a logistics story.

Quote: “Today, sometimes you need two to three vessels per load to get it out because you’re doing what is called ship-to-ship transfers.” Amrita Sen, Energy Aspects, on CNBC’s Squawk Box
My Investing News

Why the Supply-Side Story Is the Default Explanation

A WSJ headline framed the cut as Saudi exports recover. That is the conventional explanation: more barrels reach the market, buyers gain options, and the seller trims its price to place those barrels.

Line chart: Tanker owners more than doubled while crude rose about half. $100 invested on Oct. 3, 2025 was worth $289 in International Seaways (up 188.7%), $267 in Frontline (up 166.7%), $228 in DHT (up 127.8%), $155 in Brent crude futures (up 55.5%) and $117 in the S&P 500 (up 17.0%) at the Oct. 5, 2026 close, dividends included.
My Investing News

Amrita Sen Points to a $30 Delivery Bill

Sen attributes the cut to what it now costs to physically move crude out of the Gulf. By her firm’s estimate, shipping oil from Hormuz to Asia currently costs about $30 per barrel, an increase she describes as fivefold versus historical averages, according to investingLive. A separate WSJ headline on Monday noted that Hormuz shipping risks persist even as the G-7 plans a crude and diesel release.

How Ship-to-Ship Transfers Inflate the Cost of Every Barrel

According to Sen, crude must be moved from one tanker to another at sea, a process called a ship-to-ship transfer, sometimes several times on a single journey. One cargo movement used to need a single vessel. Sen says it can now require two to three vessels, and ship-to-ship transfers and dark transits now take two to three weeks.

Each extra vessel adds charter time and handling costs. When delivery costs climb that sharply, a producer can pass the cost to the buyer and risk losing the sale, or bear the cost by lowering its headline price. In Sen’s reading, the November cut is Saudi Arabia bearing the logistics bill.

Saudi Arabia’s November price for Asia

Arab Light to Asia−$5A barrel below the Oman/Dubai average, widest discount since June 2020
Change from October−$3Reuters survey had expected a $3 increase
Northwest Europe+$3All grades, after Red Sea exports from Yanbu resumed
Brent futures$100.32Front-month close on Oct. 5, 2026

Sen’s Boldest Claim: Futures May Understate Real Stress

Sen’s most far-reaching statement is that delivered prices into Asia run about 40% higher than what the futures market shows. She also says the spread between Dated Brent and Brent futures reached $20 in September, compared with a historical level of about $1.

If she is right, the screen price quoted in nearly every headline differs from what refiners actually pay, and the futures market is downplaying real physical stress. Investors should treat this statement of market mispricing as Sen’s view.

Weighing Both Explanations Before Drawing Conclusions

Both readings can hold at once. Exports can recover while shipping costs spike, according to WSJ. Sen’s figures come from her firm and cannot be verified against published market data, and Energy Aspects’ business rests on analyzing physical market dynamics that screen prices can miss.

Bar chart: Asia got a price cut. Europe got a price increase. Change in Saudi Aramco’s November official selling prices from October, in dollars a barrel: Arab Light to Asia down $3, Arab Medium to Asia down $5, Arab Heavy to Asia down $5, all grades to northwest Europe up $3, all grades to the U.S. unchanged.
My Investing News

What to Watch Next as the Debate Plays Out

If Sen is right, the gap between delivered Asian prices and futures should hold or widen even if crude futures stay flat, but if the consensus is right, the discount should narrow as export volumes return to normal. Saudi Arabia’s next monthly pricing announcement and the Dated Brent to futures spread are the signals worth tracking.

Saudi Arabia just slashed crude prices to six-year lows, and everyone assumes it signals a supply glut. Energy Aspects founder Amrita Sen thinks the real culprit is something far stranger happening at sea.

The bottom line

Sen argues that the soaring cost of moving crude out of the Gulf, which she puts at about $30 a barrel, explains Saudi Arabia’s deep November discount for Asia. Her figures come from her own firm, and the risk to her view is that freight costs ease as exports recover, which would let the discount close.

To top