Where we heard itCNBC’s The Closer, “Taking a bite out of McDonald’s as shares hover near a 52 week low,” Oct. 5, 2026. Speakers: Jon Tower, equity research analyst at Citi, and Greg Francfort, lead restaurant analyst at Guggenheim Securities. Watch at CNBC
Before considering what two Wall Street analysts said about McDonald’sMCD, start with the number neither of them mentioned. As of the October 5, 2026 close, McDonald’s has delivered a 6.8% total return over the past five years. Including dividends, the stock has declined 20.6% over the past year and 22.3% year to date. Shares closed at $233.04 on October 5.
Any claim that a turnaround is priced in must account for a five-year stretch in which the stock barely moved.

Billions Committed After an Investor Day Sell-Off
At its September 23 investor day, McDonald’s said it plans to provide about $8.5 billion in support to franchisees through 2036, through rent relief and capital support, to modernize restaurants across a system of more than 46,000 locations, according to the company’s investor day release. The rest depends on franchisees.

Citi analyst Jon Tower rates the stock a buy. Guggenheim Securities analyst Greg Francfort rates it neutral. They took opposite sides on CNBC.
Tower’s Case Rests on Real Estate Leverage
Tower argues that “a lot” of the transformation’s cost is already priced into the stock. His structural argument is about property. McDonald’s controls the real estate, which he says gives it “the stick and the carrot” with franchisees.
What McDonald’s offered franchisees at its investor day
Tower projects that over 5 to 10 years, competitors will have a smaller asset base in the core U.S. market, McDonald’s will narrow the gap against specialist chains globally, and it will win share from more affluent customers.
Tower points to the negative trade on consumer stocks globally and sector pressures, including GLP-1 drugs. He expects investors to return to the name as the year ends and into 2027 and reconsider the price.
Francfort Asks Whether Operators Will Pay
Francfort sees a gap between what corporate wants franchisees to pay and what they will actually pay, calling it “a big challenge for the business.”
Francfort says each operator is being asked to put $1.2 million to $1.3 million back into their stores over the next several years. He says he wants to see whether they commit or push back.
His evidence comes from the ten items under $3 value menu rollout, where 40% to 45% of franchisees did not execute agreed price points. That figure records what operators actually did, making it the most concrete data point in the debate.
Context the CNBC Segment Skipped
Tower’s buy rating is more contrarian than a two-sided debate suggests. Investing.com reported that JPMorgan cut its McDonald’s price target on the reinvestment plan, in a piece published September 24, 2026. A forbes.com piece from September 25, 2026 argued the comeback plan could make things worse.
Francfort’s concern has outside support. Restaurant Business Magazine reported on August 24, 2026 that McDonald’s franchisee profitability takes a hit just as the company eyes renovations.

Leverage Versus Capacity
Both analysts accept the plan is expensive and necessary. Tower’s answer rests on leverage, since McDonald’s owns the real estate. Francfort’s rests on capacity, since operators pressured by labor and food costs may lack the money.
Tower described the stock as trading at under about 17 times forward earnings. That is his figure.
Separately, McDonald’s trailing price-to-earnings ratio was about 19 at the October 5 close. Company SEC filings and presentations are on McDonald’s investor relations site.
A Test That Takes Years to Grade
Francfort named the test: whether franchisees actually spend the money. Tower’s thesis runs 5 to 10 years out. The bull case has a much longer runway before anyone can grade it.
Tower thinks the cost of McDonald’s reinvestment is largely priced in and that owning the real estate gives it the pull to get franchisees on board. Francfort wants proof first, after 40% to 45% of operators skipped agreed value-menu prices. The risk for buyers is that a stock with a 6.8% five-year return needs franchisees to spend money while their own profits are under pressure.