Home

 › 

Retirement

 › 

Wharton’s Kent Smetters Says Even an AI Boom Wouldn’t Fix Social Security. The Trustees’ Own Math Shows Faster Wage Growth Closes Only 26% of the Gap

Chart: faster real wage growth, the Trustees’ optimistic case, would close 26% of Social Security’s 75-year shortfall, against 58% for taxing all wages and 101% for raising the payroll tax to 17% now.

Wharton’s Kent Smetters Says Even an AI Boom Wouldn’t Fix Social Security. The Trustees’ Own Math Shows Faster Wage Growth Closes Only 26% of the Gap

Quick Read

  • A quirk in the benefit formula quietly undercuts the 'AI will save us' hope.
  • The Trustees tested a faster-growth scenario. The result may surprise optimists and skeptics alike.
  • Some levers dwarf wage growth, and one that Smetters calls a 'free lunch' comes up short in the actuaries' math.

Where we heard itBarron’s Streetwise, “America’s Debt Reckoning: 5 Paths Forward,” Nov. 6, 2026. Host Jack Hough with Kent Smetters, director of the Penn Wharton Budget Model, and Maya MacGuineas, president of the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget.

A common hope for Social Security is that artificial intelligence will make workers so productive that the economy grows its way out of the program’s shortfall. Kent Smetters, the Wharton economist who runs the Penn Wharton Budget Model, says the law itself gets in the way. On Barron’s Streetwise on Nov. 6, he noted that AI gains are already in his group’s baseline. “But suppose that we’re wrong,” he said. “Suppose that we actually double the impact of AI on productivity.” The catch, he explained, is that Social Security’s initial benefit calculation “doesn’t just account for inflation over your lifetime, it actually accounts for wage growth as well.” So when productivity lifts pay, “the tax base gets bigger, we’re all excited about that,” and the starting benefit is “also going to get bigger as well.”

Quote: “Suppose that we actually double the impact of AI on productivity. … You get very little impact for the Social Security problem that we have.” Kent Smetters, Wharton economist and director of the Penn Wharton Budget Model, on Barron’s Streetwise, Nov. 6, 2026
My Investing News
My Investing News

His conclusion: “Your ability to grow out of the problem for Social Security, it’s actually written in the law.” Smetters also said Penn Wharton and Social Security’s actuaries agree the trust fund runs dry in about six to seven years, leaving about 85 cents of every scheduled dollar. The 2026 Trustees Report puts the retirement fund’s depletion in the fourth quarter of 2032, with 78% of benefits payable after that, and the combined retirement and disability funds in the third quarter of 2034, with 83% payable. We tested his growth argument against the Trustees’ own numbers, which show what faster wage growth would do.

Why Higher Pay Raises Benefits Too

Smetters is describing a real feature of the benefit formula. When someone first claims, Social Security adjusts their past earnings for the growth in average wages across the economy, so a generation that earns more also starts with bigger checks. Only after that first check do raises follow prices, through the yearly cost-of-living adjustment.

The Trustees spell out the same mechanism, with a twist that cuts against him a little. “Higher wages increase taxable payroll immediately,” the report says, “but they increase benefit levels only gradually as new beneficiaries become entitled.” Retirees already collecting get price raises, not wage raises. So faster wage growth helps, just not by enough to close the gap. (Faster pay growth on paper doesn’t always reach every household, as the Fed’s latest survey of lower earners showed.)

The Trustees’ Own Test: A Quarter of the Gap

The report’s sensitivity analysis changes one assumption at a time. Under the middle forecast, average real wages grow 1.14% a year from 2035 on. In the optimistic case, 1.74% a year, about half again as fast, Social Security’s 75-year shortfall shrinks from 4.42% of taxable payroll to 3.27%. That closes 26% of the gap. The combined funds would last until 2035, one year longer than in the middle forecast. The Trustees’ rule of thumb: every extra tenth of a point of real wage growth improves the balance by about 0.19% of payroll.

Smetters’ doubling scenario goes beyond anything the Trustees test. Their middle forecast assumes productivity grows 1.63% a year, close to the 1.60% average from 1969 to 2019, and their optimistic case assumes 1.93%. Productivity has averaged 1.80% since 2019. On the near-term question he raised, the date, the Trustees agree with him: faster wages barely move it. On the 75-year gap, they help more than “very little,” though most of the hole remains.

Bar chart: share of Social Security’s 75-year shortfall of 4.42% of taxable payroll that each change would close. Raise payroll tax to 17% now: 101%; Tax all wages, no added benefits: 58%; Tax all wages, with added benefits: 45%; Faster wage growth (1.74% a year): 26%; Higher fertility (2.1 children): 17%; Raise payroll tax to 13% by 2034: 12%; More immigration (1.6 million a year): 10%. The economic changes are the 2026 Trustees Report’s optimistic assumptions, with all else at the intermediate assumptions; the tax changes are SSA chief actuary estimates.
My Investing News
My Investing News

What Moves the Gap More

Social Security’s Office of the Chief Actuary prices dozens of policy changes against the same baseline. Raising the 12.4% payroll tax to 17% starting in 2027 would close 101% of the 75-year gap. A gentler path, to 13% by 2034, closes 12%. Taxing all wages above the cap, which is $184,500 this year and $192,300 in 2027, would close 58% if those earnings earned no extra benefits and 45% if they did.

Social Security’s 75-year shortfall, 2026 Trustees Report

Shortfall, share of taxable payroll4.42%Over 2026 to 2100
Faster real wage growth+1.15 ptsCloses 26% of the gap
More immigration+0.42 ptsCloses 10% of the gap
Retirement fund runs dryLate 2032Then 78% of benefits payable

Smetters called legal immigration the closest thing to “a free lunch,” saying immigrants “pay way more in taxes than they collect in benefits.” In the Trustees’ numbers, raising average net immigration from about 1.18 million to 1.62 million a year closes 10% of the gap, with each extra 100,000 people a year worth about 0.10% of payroll. He was also talking about the wider federal budget, which this test doesn’t cover. Higher birth rates, 2.1 children per woman instead of 1.75, would close 17%.

Put all of the optimistic assumptions together, including 1.93% productivity growth, more immigration and higher fertility, and the retirement fund still runs dry in 2035, three years after the middle forecast, with 89% of benefits payable. In the pessimistic case it empties in 2031.

Line chart of the Social Security retirement (OASI) trust fund ratio from 2026 under the 2026 Trustees Report’s three scenarios, all starting at 153%. Pessimistic: 17% at the start of 2031, run out in 2031. Intermediate: 17% at the start of 2032, run out in late 2032. Optimistic: 3% at the start of 2035, run out in 2035.
My Investing News
My Investing News

What to Watch

The Trustees’ next report, due in 2027, will be the first full test of whether stronger wage data change the date. This year’s report already credited faster near-term earnings growth, and the combined funds’ date still didn’t budge. The depletion year has moved many times before, as every Trustees forecast since 1983 shows. MacGuineas, on the same episode, argued that a commission “could actually be part of the solution,” because “there will be many, many more political attack ads than there will be appreciation for fixing the system.” For households, the practical point is the same either way: how much a retirement portfolio can safely pay out matters more if checks are cut.

The bottom line

Smetters is right that Social Security can’t simply grow its way out: because benefits rise with wages, the Trustees’ optimistic wage case moves the depletion date by one year and closes 26% of the 75-year gap. Taxes do more of the work in the actuaries’ estimates, with an uncapped payroll tax closing 45% to 58%. The risk to his view is an AI boom far bigger than anything the Trustees test.

To top