Home

 › 

Economy

 › 

The NRF Expects Holiday Sales to Pass $1 Trillion for the First Time. Its Forecasts Have Missed by an Average 1.4 Points Since 2010

Chart: how far actual holiday sales growth landed from the National Retail Federation’s forecast each season from 2010 to 2025, in percentage points. The miss averaged 1.4 points, above and below. In 2025 sales grew 3.1% against a forecast of 3.7% to 4.2%.

The NRF Expects Holiday Sales to Pass $1 Trillion for the First Time. Its Forecasts Have Missed by an Average 1.4 Points Since 2010

Quick Read

  • A trillion-dollar forecast sounds bold until you learn how little cushion it actually has.
  • NRF made this exact promise a year ago, and the Census Bureau later changed the math behind it.
  • One early-season gauge flagged last year's miss. Does it point the same way this time?

Where we heard itMatthew Shay, president and CEO of the National Retail Federation, in NRF’s 2026 holiday forecast, released Oct. 15, 2026.

The National Retail Federation says this is the year holiday shopping crosses $1 trillion. In its Oct. 15 forecast, the trade group said sales in November and December will grow 4.2% from last year to $1.013 trillion, after rising 3.1% to $972 billion in 2025. NRF’s president and CEO put it this way:

Quote: “This year’s forecast reflects our confidence that consumers will prioritize the holiday season even as they remain mindful of their budgets.” Matthew Shay, president and CEO, National Retail Federation, Oct. 15, 2026
My Investing News
My Investing News

NRF’s forecast is the most quoted number of the shopping season, so we scored it. For every season since 2010, we lined up the first forecast NRF announced in the fall against the growth NRF itself reported once the Census Bureau’s numbers came in. NRF counts retail sales from Nov. 1 through Dec. 31, leaving out car dealers, gas stations and restaurants, and doesn’t adjust for inflation.

Off by 1.4 Points a Season

Over 16 seasons, the result landed an average of 1.4 percentage points from NRF’s forecast, measured from the midpoint when NRF gave a range. Leave out 2020 and 2021, when pandemic spending blew past every forecast, and the average miss is about 1 point. Sales beat the forecast 9 times and fell short 7 times, so the misses don’t lean hard one way.

NRF came within a tenth of a point three times, in 2013, 2014 and 2019. Its biggest miss was 2021: it forecast growth of 8.5% to 10.5%, and sales rose 14.1%. The worst shortfalls came in 2018, when sales grew 2.9% against a forecast of 4.3% to 4.8%, and in 2022, when they grew 5.3% against 6% to 8%.

Bar chart of holiday sales growth as the National Retail Federation first reported it, with its forecast for each season: 2010: actual 5.7%, forecast 2.3%; 2011: actual 4.1%, forecast 2.8%; 2012: actual 3%, forecast 4.1%; 2013: actual 3.8%, forecast 3.9%; 2014: actual 4%, forecast 4.1%; 2015: actual 3%, forecast 3.7%; 2016: actual 4%, forecast 3.6%; 2017: actual 5.5%, forecast 3.6% to 4%; 2018: actual 2.9%, forecast 4.3% to 4.8%; 2019: actual 4.1%, forecast 3.8% to 4.2%; 2020: actual 8.3%, forecast 3.6% to 5.2%; 2021: actual 14.1%, forecast 8.5% to 10.5%; 2022: actual 5.3%, forecast 6% to 8%; 2023: actual 3.8%, forecast 3% to 4%; 2024: actual 4%, forecast 2.5% to 3.5%; 2025: actual 3.1%, forecast 3.7% to 4.2%. 2026 forecast: 4.2%.
My Investing News
My Investing News

In 2017, NRF started publishing a range “rather than the usual fixed percentage,” citing that fall’s hurricanes. The ranges caught the result in two of nine seasons, 2019 and 2023. Four times sales came in above the range and three times below it. This year NRF is back to a single number, from a forecasting approach it built with Oxford Economics, as it explained in its March annual forecast.

The Trillion That Came and Went

NRF made the same call a year ago. Its Nov. 6, 2025 release was titled “NRF Expects Holiday Sales to Surpass $1 Trillion for the First Time in 2025,” on growth of 3.7% to 4.2%. In January, using card data from its CNBC/NRF Retail Monitor, NRF said 2025 holiday sales grew 4.1%, “near the top of NRF’s forecast.”

The Census numbers then moved under it. On the data as published before September, NRF’s definition of holiday sales comes to $1.011 trillion for 2025, up 3.6%, by our calculation. The Census Bureau’s annual revision on Sept. 28 cut both. The current figures put the season at $972.3 billion, up 3.1%, which matches what NRF now reports. The same revision lowered 2024’s growth to 3.6% from the 4.3% NRF cited a year ago.

Revisions make the record look worse. Against today’s Census figures, none of NRF’s nine ranges since 2017 contains the result, and the average miss grows to 1.7 points. A forecaster can’t see a benchmark revision coming, which is why our scorecard uses the numbers NRF first reported.

NRF’s holiday forecast, scored

2026 forecast$1.013TUp 4.2% from 2025
2025 result+3.1%Forecast: 3.7% to 4.2%
Seasons inside NRF’s range2 of 9Ranges since 2017
Average miss1.4 pts16 seasons, 2010 to 2025

What a 1.4-Point Miss Means for $1 Trillion

From last year’s revised $972.3 billion, sales need to grow about 2.85% to pass $1 trillion. So the milestone has some cushion, though not much. A shortfall the size of NRF’s average miss, from 4.2% down to about 2.8%, would land near $999 billion, just under the line. NRF’s forecast has run that far too high only twice in 16 seasons, in 2018 and 2022.

Some of the growth will be prices. Consumer prices were 3.7% higher in September than a year earlier, the Bureau of Labor Statistics said, and NRF’s total counts dollars, not units. NRF chief economist Mark Mathews flagged the strain in the release: “At the same time, inflation, rising gas prices and pressure on household spending will affect consumers differently across income groups.” Gas was about $4 a gallon heading into Thanksgiving, a holiday record before adjusting for inflation.

What the Season So Far Says

Going in, store sales were running ahead of the forecast. The Census Bureau’s advance estimates of retail sales, excluding autos and parts, gas stations and restaurants, were 4.6% above a year earlier in September and up 4.2% for the first nine months of 2026. NRF’s own Retail Monitor, built from card data, showed a slower 3.73% gain in core sales for September.

Line chart of U.S. retail sales excluding autos and parts, gas stations and restaurants, change from a year earlier, by month from January 2025 to September 2026, against the National Retail Federation’s 4.2% holiday forecast. Growth averaged 3.9% in 2025 and was 4.6% in September 2026. From January to September 2026, sales were up 4.2% from a year earlier.
My Investing News
My Investing News

The same gauge flagged last year’s miss. In September 2025 it was running 3.2% above a year earlier, below the 3.7% to 4.2% NRF forecast weeks later, and the season came in at 3.1%. This year the gauge sits above the forecast. Shoppers are still choosy: Kroger’s CEO has called them resilient but more intentional, and FINRA found a record share of households spending more than they earn.

What to Watch

The Census Bureau’s November retail sales figures are due Dec. 16, the first official read on the season, and the full season won’t be known until the December report in January. NRF’s Retail Monitor fills in each month with card data. Then comes next September’s annual revision, which can move the answer again, as it did for 2025.

The bottom line

NRF expects 4.2% growth and the first $1 trillion holiday season, a call it also made last year. Since 2010 its first forecast has missed by 1.4 points on average, and a miss that size to the low side would leave sales just under $1 trillion. Sales were running at 4.6% going into the season, a better start than last year’s.

To top